Best Ever Homemade Vanilla Icing Recipe

This really is the best homemade vanilla icing recipe! It’s perfect for slathering on cinnamon rolls and drizzling over cakes and cookies!

How many of you went straight for the cup of vanilla icing at the end of the cinnamon rolls packages as a kid? And how many of you were disappointed that it never seemed to be enough to adequately coat them? Yeah, I was that kid.

I mean really though, can you ever have enough icing? It’s so gooey and sweet and delicious and gooey… I said that already, didn’t I? Well, anyway, I truly think the center of a cinnamon roll doused in a creamy vanilla icing is one of the best bites of food in the world.

Homemade Vanilla Icing

PIN IT TO YOUR DRINKS BOARD ON PINTEREST!

FOLLOW SUGAR & SOUL ON PINTEREST FOR MORE RECIPES!

When I was growing up, I always learned how to make homemade icing with two things: powdered sugar and water. And most internet searches for a vanilla icing recipe will list those very two ingredients, but I can promise you they are doing you a HUGE disservice because there is a far better way to make it!

You see when you only add water, you basically get a sugar paste, and hey, there’s really nothing wrong with that. But I know that what you really want is an out of this world icing, one that’s thick and creamy and laced with notes of vanilla.

That’s why my recipe is made with heavy cream and vanilla extract. That’s right, not even milk will cut it, it’s gotta be cream. I can’t ever tell you how much of a game changer this is from a basic water and powdered sugar combo. You just have to try it for yourself!

Try This Vanilla Icing Recipe On:

• Snickerdoodle Cinnamon Rolls
• Old Fashioned Apple Cake
• Honey Cake

So let’s talk about what this icing is and what it isn’t. This icing is great for cinnamon rolls, cakes, cookies, and hot dogs (that’s my husband’s recommendation, you can try it if you want, but don’t blame me if you don’t like it, capisce?).

This icing is NOT royal icing, they are very different and made with different ingredients and methods, this icing will not maintain form like a royal icing will.

So while you can ice cookies with this recipe, it should be more of the dipped and drizzle icing method, don’t try and attempt any of the crazy cookie decorating you see in those viral videos.

This icing is NOT a frosting, so while you can dress a cake with it, it’s not going to be thick like a vanilla buttercream. But like a buttercream, it’s very important that you don’t overmix the icing because it can break.

What you’ll need for this vanilla icing recipe:

• A Whisk – For best results, you should use a whisk for this recipe, it will work better than a fork or a spoon.
• Powdered Sugar – Make sure that the sugar you’re using is soft, powdered sugar can harden over time, so if it is hard, run it through a sifter.
• Vanilla Extract – You don’t want to use that imitation crap, you want the good stuff, the REAL stuff. You can make it yourself at home or buy a high-quality bottle of it.